BILLBOARD News Now

MAGA Gets What It Deserves

MAGA Gets What It Deserves

(Editor’s note:  David French is an American political commentator and former attorney.  He is a New York Times Opinion columnist, writing about law, culture and religion.)

There is one number that stands out above all others as I think through the meaning of the midterms: 13.

As I type this, Democrats are on track to achieve a 13-point margin in the total popular vote for the House of Representatives. If you put that in presidential terms, our nation hasn’t seen a margin like that since 1984, when Ronald Reagan swept the popular vote and won 49 states.

If you compare that margin to previous midterms, the American people haven’t spoken that clearly since 1974, the first midterm after Watergate.

That’s not the only important number, of course. There’s 81, the projected Democratic margin in the House. There’s 56, the possible number of Democratic senators (if Mississippi and Alaska go blue). And there’s 26, the potential percentage of the statewide swing (from Trump plus-14 in 2024 to Talarico plus-12 in 2026) that turned Texas blue.

I’m going to say that again — that turned Texas blue.

The Democrats hadn’t won a statewide race there since 1994, and then James Talarico led an epic rout. Republicans lost every single significant statewide race. Even the Republican State Supreme Court justices lost their races.

Over the last quarter-century of tight races and extreme partisan polarization, we’ve grown used to election analysis that requires poring over exit polls, agonizing over messaging mistakes, and parsing the impact of different issues and scandals.

Perhaps the paradigmatic example is the 2016 presidential election.

Did Donald Trump win because Antonin Scalia died and Republicans held their nose and voted for him to save Scalia’s seat? Maybe. Did Trump also win because the James Comey letter reopening the Hillary Clinton email investigation chased the “Access Hollywood” tape out of the headlines? Possibly.

Or did Hillary Clinton lose because she didn’t spend enough time in Wisconsin, Michigan and Pennsylvania? Perhaps. Or did she lose simply because 2016 was a change election, and she represented the establishment? That could be, too.

But that kind of analysis is completely inappropriate in an election this decisive. In the aftermath of a wipeout of biblical proportions, it’s better to begin our analysis with one of my favorite biblical passages: “Pride goes before destruction, a haughty spirit before a fall.”

Or, put another way, it’s as if we pulled away the algae from Trump’s filthy Reflecting Pool, and found an inscription that read, “My name is Trump, king of kings: Look on my renovations, ye Mighty, and despair!”

That’s right: It’s the Ozymandias election.

It is difficult to overstate the sheer arrogance of Trump and his remaining MAGA base. They treated the rest of the people of this country as if they were of no consequence.

Actually, it’s worse than that. They treated the rest of the country as if they were enemies.

To the voters who longed for peace, he gave them a unilateral, undeclared war.

To the families seeking relief from high prices, he gave tariffs.

To the voters alarmed about corruption in Washington, he made the swamp so corrupt that barons of the Gilded Age are regretting that they were born in the wrong era.

To the new Hispanic Republican voters who helped Trump win and transformed the Republican coalition, he gave brutal racial profiling and pogroms in the streets of Chicago, Minneapolis, Los Angeles and other cities.

To voters who were weary of intolerance and cancel culture, he delivered a wave of censorship unseen since Woodrow Wilson imprisoned his political opponents by the hundreds.

To voters who wanted stability in the world, he gave fractured alliances and embraced Vladimir Putin, the world’s deadliest and most dangerous dictator.

And then, when dissenting Americans — including dissenting conservatives — condemned these outrages and cried out for relief, they were treated with contempt and rage.

The cancel culture of the MAGA right inflicted immense cruelty on its enemies, and MAGA relished their pain.

It would be a grave mistake to lay the blame for all this pride and arrogance on Trump alone. Last month I wrote that every institution eventually takes on the character of its leader, and so it is with Trump’s Republican Party.

The cult of Trump was so comprehensive, so all-consuming, that it became virtually impossible to succeed anywhere, at any level of Republican politics, without explicitly swearing fealty to Trump — and not just once but again and again, whenever you were asked to do so.

There was no better way to pledge loyalty to Trump than by acting like Trump.

That’s why a loathsome politician like Vivek Ramaswamy runs an ad exploiting the rape of a child. That’s why an equally loathsome politician like JD Vance spreads gross lies about immigrants far and wide even as innocent people suffer from the pain and shame that he caused.

That’s why grotesque racists like Bo French felt that they had a home in the Republican Party. After all, if the president can condemn entire groups of immigrants based on their countries of origin, then why can’t every other Republican who wants to broadcast his own bigotry do so? That’s why hundreds of thousands of Texas primary voters could look at Ken Paxton — and all of his adultery and corruption — and say, “Yep. That’s exactly the man we need in the Senate.”

If a MAGA voter is bewildered today, perhaps he should stop making a meme calling his opponents “fake and gay,” delete the post declaring that Indian Americans worship demons, turn off the podcast that’s shrieking at him that every person who votes Democratic is a heretic, and take a very long and thoughtful look in the mirror.

A guy can dream.

Donald Trump is to blame, but no one — absolutely no one — made you imitate him.

One thing that struck me when I traveled down to Texas to report on the Talarico-Paxton race was the combination of anger and fear emanating from Paxton’s Republican opponents.

They weren’t just angry at Paxton for challenging and beating the longtime incumbent, John Cornyn. They were furious at Paxton’s supporters, the people who’d insulted them, mocked them and hounded them out of Republican politics. They wouldn’t go on the record with their support for Talarico, but it was easy to see where they stood.

Midterm wipeouts don’t have to be fatal to parties (though they can signal a party’s demise). The Republicans almost held the White House in 1976, just two years after the 1974 election I mentioned earlier nearly wiped out the Nixon-era G.O.P. Bill Clinton was re-elected two years after the Republican revolution of 1994, and Barack Obama won after the Tea Party movement erupted in 2010.

But in those previous elections, the parties that experienced serious losses in the midterms were ultimately led by responsible adults who could react and respond to voters’ concerns, adjust policies and tactics, and revitalize their parties’ fortunes.

But Donald Trump is not Bill Clinton. He’s not Barack Obama. He’s not even Gerald Ford, who had the dignity and integrity to salvage the Republican brand after Watergate.

At least when Ford was trying to rebuild the Republican Party, the “crook” wasn’t still in the White House. In 2027, the Republicans will be trying to pick up the pieces with a crook in control of the Oval Office and his own cult of personality.

Trump is an erratic, egomaniac tinpot tyrant in decline who will blame everyone but himself for the loss. In fact, that’s already started. In a Truth Social post Tuesday night, he said that Fox News “bears responsibility for these losses by constantly and consistently putting on the Dumocrat opposition, and worse.”

There you have it. The problem with the 2026 midterms was that Fox News wasn’t sycophantic enough.

And there’s another thing — as a practical matter, every faction of the Republican Party has a reason to blame a different faction for its defeat. The circular firing squad has started, and every part of it has plenty of ammunition.

Free-trade Republicans are blaming the tariffs. America first Republicans are blaming the Iran war. (In an X post on Wednesday morning, Vance wrote, “The reason we lost is the war.”) Hispanic Republicans can blame ICE. South Asian Republicans can blame Bo French. Anti-woke Republicans can blame Trump’s crackdown on free speech.

They would all be correct, at least to some degree. They made the conscious decision to follow, defend and pledge allegiance to an unstable, hateful man, and now — at long last — they’re experiencing the inevitable consequences of their inexcusable moral compromises.

The next few days and weeks will be filled with conversation and debate over what the Democrats should do next. The easiest possible advice is to focus like a laser on the voters’ overwhelming concerns — corruption and the cost of living — but it’s now quite possible that our nation could be looking at a generational realignment.

That’s a conversation for another day. For now, we can sum up everything that happened in the midterms in three words, words that the MAGA movement has scorned for 10 years: Character is destiny. 

(Footnote:  We try to limit sharing pieces we read from outside publications.  However, with the 2028 presidential campaign underway more national news and opinions are being generated.)

Use icons and envelope above to forward this post to your friends.

Follow us on Twitter (X), Bluesky, Instagram, Facebook or Threads.

For Political Junkies

For Political Junkies

(Editor’s note:  Three respected reporters/authors with White House connections prepared this New York Times article about how an unpopular president and an unpopular war provided an opening for Democrats to make sweeping gains in the midterms.  Maggie Haberman, Shane...

read more
Movin’ On

Movin’ On

The 2028 presidential campaign started last night at 12:01 AM.  Prior to the earth-shaking results of the midterm elections, one would expect the focus to be on Democrats thinking about a 2028 run.  Republicans with close Trump ties were expected to consider running,...

read more
Case for Historic Wave

Case for Historic Wave

(Editor’s note: Peggy Noonan is one of America’s most respected writers & columnist of the Wall Street Journal.  She addresses the only way the Republican Party can be rebuilt is the President should be dealt a rebuke, a rebellion and a rout.  She also has a...

read more
What Is Next?

What Is Next?

It’s time to start thinking about what could happen when the results of the November 3rd election are known. President Trump has never seen an election he did not say was stolen.  The question is what will he do if his MAGA party or “chosen ones” do not win control of...

read more
In Sight?

In Sight?

(Editor’s note: Reading the Los Angeles Times came upon this commentary by Robin Abcarian.  She covers a wide range of topics, news, politics, culture, and societal issues, with a focus on elections, public policy and civil rights.  She is recognized for her...

read more
Consider

Consider

(Editor’s note: A thoughtful all-encompassing editorial appeared in today’s New York Times.  With our country voting over the next week…until Tuesday, November 3rd this deserves consideration.) President Trump has encouraged voters to pretend he is on the ballot for...

read more
ALERT

ALERT

This is written to alert our readers to the importance of being prepared for what our country could face between now and election day. So far, President Trump has failed in his efforts to assert federal controls over elections.  First, he tried to get his hands on...

read more
Bush Advice

Bush Advice

The time has arrived for former President George W. Bush to follow the example set by his brother Neil Bush and his daughter Barbara Bush.  They are publicly supporting Talarico in the Texas Senate race. I have supported President Bush’s position to no longer engage...

read more
Political Tidbits

Political Tidbits

(Editor’s note:  For our new readers Political Tidbits are done periodically.  BTW, any tips appreciated.  Send to [email protected].)  Counting the days 17 till the election…concerned Americans are counting 808 days until Trump…his chaos and corruption…are...

read more
Trump Rejects 2-Decade Tradition

Trump Rejects 2-Decade Tradition

(Editor’s note:  The Hill reports President Trump is breaking more than two-decades of international election observers monitoring the November mid-term election.  Laura Kelly in the article below provides the history of this effort and that the USA joins isolated...

read more
“Day After”

“Day After”

(Editor’s note: Axios AM arrives each morning by Mike Allen.  Below is todays focused on A1 labs war-game “the day after”.) Top executives at Anthropic, OpenAI and other AI companies are privately gaming out scenarios for a public and political revolt after a...

read more
A 2028 Approach

A 2028 Approach

(Editor’s note: There is a significant amount of dissatisfaction with the two-party system.  Former WV Senator Joe Manchin in a Washington Post Op Ed says, “voters do not need another political party…they need independent-minded leaders willing to put the country...

read more

BILLBOARD Archives

Advice from the Master

Advice from the Master

(Editor’s note: Karl Rove has a weekly column in The Wall Street Journal.  Today he says “The GOP strategy looks good on paper.  “What’s lacking is competent execution.”  Rove guided Governor George W. Bush’s 2000 campaign and served as Senior Advisor and Deputy Chief...

read more
Trump Brand Has Tanked

Trump Brand Has Tanked

(Editor’s note:  Kristen Soltis Anderson is an American Republican pollster, speaker, author and media commentator.  She is the author of “The Selfie Vote: Where Millennials Are Leading American (and How Republicans Can Keep Up).  She has a piece in today’s New York...

read more
Trump Should Stop Hosting Summits

Trump Should Stop Hosting Summits

(Editor’s Note:  Tom Nichols writes for The Atlantic, the article below released late this morning is how President Trump has turned summits into a pointless ritual. Nicholas is a professor emeritus of the national-security affairs at the U.S. Naval War College, and...

read more
Trump’s future foretold

Trump’s future foretold

(Editor’s note:  Jim VandeHei & Mike Allen of Axios periodically write a column “Behind the Curtain.  This morning’s foretells Trump’s future.) President Trump feels and acts invincible: He acts on whims, however he pleases, precedent and restraints be damned. But...

read more
“I’ll have no part of it”

“I’ll have no part of it”

“I’ll have no part of it” Karl Rove, one of America’s most respected Republican voices hopefully has lit a fire with current and former members of the Republican Party.  Last week he exploded when Republican BO French, candidate for Texas Railroad Commission posted a...

read more
Our Freedom At Risk

Our Freedom At Risk

Today American democracy is more at risk than at any point since the 1960’s.  Nothing makes that point stronger than the President of the United States abruptly ordering the removal of major traditional news media from covering the White House.  Telling CNN, MS Now...

read more
Pause AI for Humanity’s Sake

Pause AI for Humanity’s Sake

(Editor’s Note: Peggy Noonan wrote the piece below which has resulted in AI becoming the scariest political issue & talked about in the country today.  Ms. Noonan is a Pulitzer Prize winning author and Wall Street Journal opinion columnist.) There is no subject...

read more
Let’s Pretend

Let’s Pretend

President Trump gathered what few supporters he has last night to play “Let’s Pretend”.  They all charged to Dallas to pay their final respects to a dying presidency.  Before the final rites were pronounced on election day November 3rd, he asks the adoring friends to...

read more
Not So Supreme, Mr. Roberts

Not So Supreme, Mr. Roberts

(Editor's note:  This morning Maureen Dowd, opinion columnist for The New York Times, wrote the piece below.  Ms. Dowd is an American Journalist, best-selling author, and Pulitzer Prize-winning writers.) It’s crazy to think about Donald Trump outrunning anything. But...

read more
Publishers Message

Publishers Message

We heard from our readers after recently publishing articles and opinion pieces from respected authors, journals & newspapers.  They suggested we do more.  We plan to do so but will continue to offer our own commentary and ideas.  Suggestions are always welcome at...

read more
Not Time for Silence

Not Time for Silence

President Trump has us in a fix.  All the while he sits at the resolute desk coloring maps, renaming Lake Ontario and contemplating a new name for an ocean.  He has us in a trade war, a real war, an affordability crisis, deportation of our neighbors, fighting with a...

read more
4 Political Junkies

4 Political Junkies

(Editor’s note: Moments ago, The Atlantic published a politics piece by Yvonne Wingett Sanchez, Michael Scherer and Ashley Parker.) Trump Plans to Buy Midterm Ads About His Own Record.   President Trump gathered his top political advisers in the Oval Office early this...

read more
Skip to content